I have been posting notes here for some years now since I retired as a teacher of English and as an Advising Examiner for English Higher Level for many years. What I have done here is bring all those links together in one post or blog – as a kind of Index of all the posts I’ve written that are specifically relevant to Leaving Cert English 2024 – to save you the trouble of constantly searching the internet each time you want to do some background work on a text or a poet or author. It’s not perfect and it won’t suit every student, class, or teacher – you may have already made different text choices from the many available. It’s my version of a ‘One-Stop Shop’ and you know the drill: just click on the link if it’s relevant to your studies! My choice of texts is personal and obviously will not suit every teacher, every student, or every class. You can easily see where my own preferences lie by simply viewing the number of links provided for each text or poet!
However, Caveat Emptor! Leaving Cert Student Beware !! These are resources that you should use wisely. They are my personal responses to the various texts and you should read and consider them and decide to study them if you find them useful. IN OTHER WORDS, MAKE YOUR OWN OF THEM, ADD TO THEM, OR DELETE FROM THEM AS YOU SEE FIT.
Single Text
Hamlet (H/O)
Hamlet’s Antic Disposition: That is the Question!
The Problem with Hamlet is Hamlet
Polonius and his family in Hamlet
Comparisons and Contrasts in Hamlet
Ghosts and the Supernatural in Hamlet
Silas Marner (O)
Fairy-Tale Elements in Silas Marner
Silas Marner by George Eliot is a radically disturbing social document
Philadelphia, Here I Come! (O)
Characters and Relationships in Philadelphia Here I Come!
The Theme of Communication in Philadelphia Here I Come!
The Theme of Escape in Philadelphia Here I Come!
Comparative Section
MODES OF COMPARISON
For each Leaving Certificate course, three modes of comparison will be prescribed. This means that the texts chosen for comparative study must be studied under these particular modes (headings).
This year the modes of comparison at Higher Level are as follows:
- Literary Genre
- Theme or Issue
- Cultural Context
Two of these three will be examined in June 2024.
Literary Genre
This mode focuses on the ways that texts tell their story. This is also a legitimate basis for comparison: whether it is a tragic play, a detective thriller, a film, a historical novel, an autobiography or a travel book. (The amazing thing is that all these differing genres are available for study on your Leaving Cert course!).
The following questions should be asked about the texts being studied by you:
- How is this story told? (Who tells it? Where and when is it told?)
- Why is the story told in this way?
- What effects do all these have?
- Is there just one plot or many plots? How do these relate?
- What are the major tensions in the texts? Are they resolved or not?
- Was this way of telling the story successful and enjoyable?
- How do the texts compare as stories?
- Is the story humorous or tragic, romantic or realistic?
- To what genre does it actually belong?
- Because your three texts are so different you have to be very aware of how different the experience of encountering a novel, a play, and viewing a film is.
Theme or Issue
This involves comparing texts on a prescribed theme. These would have to be themes that were pervasive and central to the texts chosen for study e.g.
- Isolation and Loneliness.
- Relationships and love.
- Fantasy and reality.
These themes/issues will be the messages or concerns that the writer or film director wishes to impart to the audience. In most texts, there will be a number of themes/issues worth considering
Your task, therefore, in this section is to compare and contrast the same theme as it is treated by different authors or film directors.
Cultural Context
Compare the texts focusing on social rituals, values, and attitudes. This is not to be seen as a sociological study of the texts alone. It means taking some perspectives, which enable the students to understand the kind of values and structures with which people contend. It amounts to entering into the world of the text and getting some insight and feel for the cultural texture of the world created. This would imply considering such aspects as the rituals of life and the routines of living, the structures of society, familial, social, economic, religious, and political: the respective roles of men and women in society, the position of children, the role and nature of work, the sources and structures of power and the significance of race and class.
When you answer a question in the Comparative Section remember that you have to be selective in emphasising the most meaningful similarities and differences between texts. The more similar they appear to be, the more provocative and challenging it is to contrast them and to draw out differences between them. Remember also that when you draw out surprising or disputable similarities or differences, you require detailed support from the texts.
In a Comparative answer, it is vitally important to compare and contrast these different ways of looking at life, or to examine if there is coherence or a lack of coherence between all these differing viewpoints.
Pride and Prejudice
Character Study of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr Darcy in Pride and Prejudice
The Themes of Pride and Prejudice in Pride and Prejudice
The Theme of Marriage in Pride and Prejudice
Philadelphia, Here I Come!
Characters and Relationships in Philadelphia Here I Come!
The Theme of Communication in Philadelphia Here I Come!
The Theme of Escape in Philadelphia Here I Come!
Silas Marner
Fairy-Tale Elements in Silas Marner
Silas Marner by George Eliot is a radically disturbing social document
Macbeth
Macbeth: Order violated, order restored.
Macbeth: From Centrality to Isolation
Macbeth: A Truly Aware Tragic Hero?
Poetry
Emily Dickinson
An Overview of the Poetry of Emily Dickinson
John Donne
An Introduction to Metaphysical Poetry
John Donne and Metaphysical Poetry
An Analysis of Some of my Favourite Poems by John Donne
Seamus Heaney
The Poetry of Seamus Heaney: Some Recurring Themes
Analysis of The Forge by Seamus Heaney
Analysis of The Harvest Bow by Seamus Heaney
The Treatment of Women in Seamus Heaney’s Poetry: a feminist critique.
Gerard Manley Hopkins
The Poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins
An Analysis of Spring by Gerard Manley Hopkins
An Analysis of Inversnaid by Gerard Manley Hopkins
Analysis of The Windhover by Gerard Manley Hopkins
Commentary on Pied Beauty by Hopkins
The Terrible Sonnets are not so terrible after all!
Hi Vincent
I’m writing on behalf of my daughter who is currently in leaving cert as I shared your most recent post with her.
She has asked me if you have any resources on The Crucible as it’s very hard to get quality information online. The Crucible is her Single Text.
Her Comparative is – Where the Crawdads Sing Shawshank Redemption Macbeth
Again, it’s not that easy to find good information on Crawdads & Shawshank.
Any help would be great !
Many thanks
Ciara
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sorry Ciara that there doesn’t seem to be much in my resources to suit your daughter’s choice of texts. They are interesting though and we’ll chosen by her teacher/school. I will keep her in mind and return to you if I find some stuff in my files. Send me on an email so I can upload some stuff for her.
It may be a week or two!
Regards,
Vincent
LikeLike
Thanks a million Vincent !
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much Vincent!
Invaluable and very generous resources,
much appreciated,
Gillian
Sent from my iPhone
LikeLiked by 1 person